So, you're thinking about picking up a play by George Bernard Shaw. You might expect witty dialogue and some social commentary, and 'The Doctor's Dilemma' has that in spades. But it also has a central question that will stick with you long after you finish reading.

The Story

The story follows Sir Colenso Ridgeon, a doctor who has just been knighted for discovering a groundbreaking treatment for tuberculosis. His triumph is quickly complicated when he's faced with two dying patients and only enough of the serum for one. The first is Louis Dubedat, a young, penniless artist of immense talent but questionable morals—he's a charming liar and a bit of a scoundrel. The second is Dr. Blenkinsop, an older, kind, but utterly ordinary and unsuccessful colleague. Ridgeon is pulled in different directions: his professional duty, his personal judgment of character, and the pleas of Dubedat's devoted wife, Jennifer. The play follows Ridgeon's impossible choice and its shocking, morally messy consequences.

Why You Should Read It

What I love about this play is how Shaw refuses to let anyone off the hook, especially the 'hero,' Ridgeon. We watch a smart man tie himself in knots trying to justify a decision that might be more about his own pride and biases than pure medical ethics. Is he saving a life, or playing God? The characters aren't just symbols; they feel real and frustrating in the best way. Dubedat is infuriatingly charismatic, and you'll find yourself arguing about him. Shaw's humor is bone-dry and perfect—he skewers the pretensions of the medical profession, the art world, and society's fickle morals all at once.

Final Verdict

This is perfect for anyone who loves a smart, talky play that makes you think. If you enjoy debating ethical gray areas or characters who are deeply flawed, you'll have a field day. It's also a great pick for readers who might be intimidated by older classics, because the central dilemma is so immediate and the dialogue is fantastically sharp. Don't come looking for a tidy, feel-good ending. Come looking for a brilliant, provocative argument staged with some of the best wit in the English language.